Matt Yglesias

Jan 13th, 2009 at 11:23 am

Awkward Turtle

It’s really nutty, isn’t it, that coverage of Hillary Clinton’s confirmation hearings is being dominated by the idea that it’ll be super-awkward for John Kerry to sit in a hearing room with Hillary Clinton since he was another major candidate for the Secretary of State job?

Kerry and Clinton have both been in big-time politics for decades, I’m pretty certain they can muster the wherewithal to cooperate. The underlying supposition of this coverage seems to be that there’s some kind of shortfall of noteworthy substantive issues related to the conduct of US foreign policy that we could speculate about. And that’s nuts.






28 Responses to “Awkward Turtle”

  1. John Says:

    The underlying supposition of this coverage seems to be that there’s some kind of shortfall of noteworthy substantive issues related to the conduct of US foreign policy that we could speculate about. And that’s nuts.

    I think the underlying supposition being made by the networks is that the American people are idiots, and prefer stupid news coverage to good news coverage. It is not clear that they are wrong.

  2. Jim Says:

    Richard Lugar makes me sleepy.

  3. right Says:

    I liked the angle Kerry took in his intro, joking about how he, Clinton, Dodd, and Lugar were all wanna-be Obamas (or even Bidens).

  4. joe from Lowell Says:

    It’s daytime TV, which will be watched by people who watch daytime TV.

    So the daytime TV people set it up like a soap opera.

  5. Rob Says:

    Lets be honest, this way the people covering the event don’t even have to pretend to understand whats going on in the world. It makes the press’s job much easier and thats what really matters.

  6. phoebes in santa fe Says:

    I wonder if Kerry was “passed over” for SoS because of Ted Kennedy’s illness. I assume Kennedy has not too long to live (though he does look pretty good) and Massachusetts would lose ANY pull in the Senate if both Kennedy and Kerry are replaced.

    Just a theory.

  7. Aaron Says:

    Ah, the awkward turtle. A lifelong voter will be minted today if I catch any Senator making that gesture.

  8. mike Says:

    The press corps sucks, news at 11.

    It is nice for Yglesias to keep pointing it out though.

  9. mort Says:

    Yes, the Senators are boring; but we get Chris Matthews’ analysis.

  10. John Boonstra Says:

    liveblog happening here.

  11. Notorious P.A.T. Says:

    The press corps sucks, news at 11

    If the press sucks, why would you want to see a story from the press about it sucking?

  12. Brien Jackson Says:

    Actually I think it’s much worse than that; the underlying factor in the coverage is that the people who craft the content of major news outlets don’t actually understand these issues. There’s all sorts of reasons for that, but the most glaring is that the journalism industry has basically been walled off at the highest levels to people who don’t have degrees in journalism and didn’t spend their whole careers as a reporter. Which isn’t to demean the work reporters do, but when you’re trying to “analyze” the news, you have to have people who are actually experts on the topic. Reporters are basically experts at writing stories, and so you get an “analysis” that takes on the form of a story narrative. And everyone knows that any good story has to have a central conflict.

  13. AHG Says:

    I blame her lady-bits for making the press stoopid.

  14. goethean Says:

    Kerry is a professional, unlike those who run the media.

  15. Persia Says:

    It’s because the Beltway reporters never got past junior high school, mentally.

  16. Francisco The Man Says:

    Another good post, Matt. Yes, Kerry is indeed a professional.

  17. Guy Yedwab Says:

    Well, Senator John Kerry is a professional, but some people in politics are not.

    The point is that the news covers politics as though it was a television show. If I were creating a political drama, I would have at least one tense scene in which John Kerry struggles with his disappointment, in which he searches his soul for the strength to do the right thing… and finally, at a key moment in the hearing, decides once and for all to put his personal feelings behind him… but at what cost?

    That kind of narrative isn’t going to win you a Pulitzer, but it might win you a Golden Globe…

  18. Jonathan Says:

    I just watched Kerry question Hillary, and he could not have been more professional or respectful. It was a simple honest and friendly Q&A.

    If anything, given the questions Kerry asked, and the points he made, I’m a bit shocked that the wouldn’t have been picked for the Sec. of State position.

  19. Mike Says:

    The underlying supposition of this coverage seems to be that there’s some kind of shortfall of noteworthy substantive issues related to the conduct of US foreign policy that we could speculate about. And that’s nuts.

    That’s the downside of the Clinton nomination. You do get “the Clinton brand,” but you also get mainly coverage of the sideshow — whether its Clinton Foundation disclosure issues or interpersonal things. Not that she herself wouldn’t prefer to talk about substance. But substance is just boring when you can report on a carnival instead.

  20. viagra Says:

    viagra
    I bookmarked this site. Thank you for good job!

  21. viagra Says:

    Great site. Good info

  22. zyban Says:

    Incredible site!

  23. tramadol Says:

    tramadol
    Great site. Good info

  24. viagra brand Says:

    It is the coolest site,keep so!
    cheap brand pfizer viagra

  25. viagra cheap Says:

    Thanks for the review!
    viagra


Jump to Top

About Wonk Room | Contact Us | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy (off-site) | RSS | Donate
© 2005-2008 Center for American Progress Action Fund
imageRegisterimageimageRSSimageimageimage image
image
Advertisement

Visit Our Affiliated Sites

image image
image 

Books By Matthew Yglesias
Book Cover

Heads in the Sand

Buy the book


imageTopic Cloud


Featured

image
Subscribe to the Progress Report




Contact Matthew Yglesias
Use this form to contact blog author Matthew Yglesias.

Name:
Email:
Tip:
(required)


imageArchives


imageBlog Roll


imageAbout Matt YglesiasimageimageContact MeimageimageDonateimage