Matt Yglesias

Aug 29th, 2008 at 11:18 am

Palin’s War on Polar Bears

Polar Bear

It’s a little bit unusual to put someone on the national ticket who nobody’s ever heard of or knows anything about. Normally you want someone who has some kind of national profile, or at least is well-known to political professionals or something. Sarah Palin is more of a “hey did you know Alaska has a super-young woman as its governor?” kind of person — noteworthy for who she is, but totally unknown as an actual politician. Hence a lot of Googling this morning.

It turns out, for example, that she’s been leading on odd crusade to deny Endangered Species Act protection to polar bears. I have some friends who think polar bears are actually cuter than pandas, which is absurd, but I think we can all agree that this is a pretty cute animal — it’s not like we’re talking about a snail darter or something.

Filed under: Environment, Palin,





60 Responses to “Palin’s War on Polar Bears”

  1. El Cid Says:

    Guess you haven’t heard that it’s a big talking point among the right that polar bears are not endangered and that it’s just a liberal conspiracy to hurt business and jobs and Jesus and what not. You’ll hear this every few days as you tune past Rush Limbaugh.

  2. Gene O'Grady Says:

    Anybody ever seen a polar bear up close? Pretty formidable animal, and quite a set of claws.

    Even if cute isn’t the right word, they’re obviously an endangered species.

  3. Vincent Says:

    McCain-polar bears ‘08!

  4. Garuda Says:

    Well, I’m for saving endangered species and polar bears do look kind of cute, but if you live in Alaska, you know that a polar bear will eat you and quickly, if given a chance. That knowledge frames the issue a bit.

  5. mark f Says:

    Here in Worcester, MA, we have a polar bear. In fact, I was just watching it this past Sunday.

    Fuck you, Sarah Palin, for trying to kill Kenda.

  6. John Says:

    Don’t go after the charismatic megafauna.

  7. whisky priest Says:

    polar bears at play:

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JE-Nyt4Bmi8

  8. MplsKid Says:

    Polar bears are one of very few animals which are known to deliberately stalk, kill and eat human beings. Which is not to say that they shouldn’t be protected, of course - but they’ve never struck me as being particularly cute.

  9. Mary Says:

    Please stop harshing on polar bears. Not as cute as panda bears, but definitely cute.

  10. James Gary Says:

    Polar bears are one of very few animals which are known to deliberately stalk, kill and eat human beings.

    Well, I don’t see why they can’t still be cute while doing that.

  11. strasmangelo jones Says:

    but if you live in Alaska, you know that a polar bear will eat you and quickly, if given a chance.

    Another reason not to live in fucking Alaska.

  12. JimPortlandOR Says:

    succinct assessment of Palin of a blog commenter at another site: Dan Qayle with Tits.

  13. Josh R. Says:

    More grist for the mill, to add to her anti-Panda, pro-nepotism agenda:

    http://www.adn.com/626/story/382864.html

    The oldest Palin kid, Track, is in the Army and texted his mother after learning the news with something to the effect of “This is just so cool — I finally got my brother.”

    In a letter she e-mailed to relatives and close friends Friday after giving birth, Palin wrote, “Many people will express sympathy, but you don’t want or need that, because Trig will be a joy. You will have to trust me on this.” She wrote it in the voice of and signed it as “Trig’s Creator, Your Heavenly Father.”

  14. mark f Says:

    succinct assessment of Palin of a blog commenter at another site: Dan Qayle with Tits.

    McCain’s so senile he picked the branch manager of his Bank of America to be his running mate.

  15. Thomas Says:

    “Superyoung”? She’s 3 years younger than Obama.

  16. Eliot Says:

    C’mon, this post is just silly. The Endangered Species Act has nothing to do with protecting “cute” animals. It’s about preserving biodiversity, which is why environmentalist made an effort to protect the utterly unattractive snail darter. The ESA has no practical application with respect to pandas anyway, as there is no natural population in the United States. Nevertheless, you are right, the panda is way cuter than the polar bear.

  17. john i Says:

    This pick scares me. I believe that America, in its heart of hearts, even in this day and age, will not vote for the black guy and will pull the lever for the MILF.

  18. Kriston Capps Says:

    At least someone’s taking a sensible position on these psychopaths.

  19. ml Says:

    A.) I can’t wait for Colbert to comment on this

    B.) i hope Obama runs an ad like this:
    the narrator runs down the laundry list of reasons we need to get off our addiction to oil, maybe include the Bush quote for good measure.

    then put up the Upton Sinclair quote ‘It is difficult to get a man to understand something when his job depends on not understanding it.’ And have the Narrator recite her and her husband’s resumes.

    C.) Can we call her a welfare queen? Do Alaskans get higher payouts per kid?

  20. thalarctos Says:

    Harumph! Polar bears are much cuter than pandas.

  21. Gary F Says:

    Let’s save the polar bears so they can stalk, kill and eat Republicans.
    Oh, wait…they stalk humans

  22. Kim Says:

    Sounds like she’s one of those Republicans who’s in denial about global warming. Admitting the polar bears are endangered would be admitting global warming is real and their homes are MELTING! total non-issue, in the grand scheme of things, I know. Ther’ll be a lot of googling over the next few months!

  23. tomfodw Says:

    Polar bears are not “cute.” They are GORGEOUS. (Okay, of course their cubs are cute.) They are magnificent, stirring predators. They are also living creatures who have no choice about where they will live, unlike humans. They share this planet and have every right to do so. We have no right to make decisions that affect the lives of other species. It’s not just our planet - it’s every living creature’s planet.

  24. oddjob Says:

    Sounds like she’s one of those Republicans who’s in denial about global warming.

    I think this one’s easy. If the polar bear is endangered due to our use of fossil fuel (& that’s going to be the conclusion if it’s acknowledged that polar bears are endangered), then Alaska sooner rather than later will lose its single largest income stream - the one coming from drilling oil in Alaska.

  25. toomuchpr Says:

    Sarah Palin hates Polar Bears.

    Coca Cola uses polar bears in their holiday advertising and they invented the image of Santa Claus as we know him.

    Therefore, Sarah Palin hates Christmas.

    At least this false syllogism passes for logic in Republican circles.

  26. Rob Says:

    You all should check it out from a scientific perspective instead of political. There’s a debate in biologist circles. The polar bear is quite an amazing animal. If it’s true that the undeniable shrinking ice pack will provide less habitat and worse seal hunting for the bear than I’d say they will only survive in zoos. If they adapt to the warmer environment they could thrive.

    In any case whatever happens will, as global warming is hard to reverse in the short term.

  27. nick Says:

    Polar bears are not “cute.” They are GORGEOUS. (Okay, of course their cubs are cute.) They are magnificent, stirring predators. They are also living creatures who have no choice about where they will live, unlike humans,

    some of whom can’t even remember how many houses they live in.

    Maybe we could use McCain’s spare houses for polar bears?

  28. izzatxeaux Says:

    let’s not forget she advocates shooting wolves from helicopters - a single image of that and a drowning polar bear and there goes the mommy votet

  29. Leee Says:

    if you live in Alaska, you know that a polar bear will eat you and quickly, if given a chance.
    All things being equal, polar bears would rather have a nice, fat, tasty seal than a puny though similarly obese human, I reckon. Except that with receding ice, hunting seals is becoming less feasible for bears and so hey, Usain Bolt aside, we don’t run very fast!

    “Polar bears are kyuuut!” advocates are clearly in the pocket of the His Dark Materials lobby.

  30. Jeffrey Davis Says:

    Polar bears are great to look at but they got lifeless eyes. Black eyes. Like a doll’s eyes. When he comes at ya, doesn’t seem to be living… until he bites ya, and those black eyes roll over white and then… ah then you hear that terrible high-pitched screamin’.

  31. Julene Says:

    From my understanding of family that lives in Alaska, the polar bear issue comes down much more on the side of who pays to fund the programs to save polar bears. Alaskans say not us, because we aren’t the sole cause of global warming and can’t stop global warming ourselves - we want someone else to pay for it. Not a real “we hate polar bears” argument. Global warming is not a states issue. Not understanding that states rights are huge in these more rural (for the lack of a better word) areas - is really a downfall for Democrats. Of course, watching your environmentalist brother & sister-in-law support drilling in ANWR and be against saving the polar bears is interesting to say the least. At least they were against the big mine to set up around the rivers for salmon spawning.

  32. Loneoak Says:

    It’s one more part of McCain’s war against the bears. He’s been using an anecdote on the stump about how the federal government funded research to study grizzly bear DNA by collecting hairs. It’s actually really innovative and effective research that saved a lot of money and gives us a much better sense of how grizzly populations are doing. But hey, if it makes a good anecdote, McCain will use regardless of the consequences.

  33. McKingford Says:

    If they adapt to the warmer environment they could thrive.

    Evolution is an amazing thing. But the idea that polar bears, which have evolved over millions of years, are going to dramatically adapt to no ice (or any of the prey they hunt off it) in 20-50 years is a bit daft.

  34. tomemos Says:

    “To me, there is no such thing as a secret world of the bears, and this blank stare speaks only of a half-bored interest in food.” –Werner Herzog

  35. Jeffey Davis Says:

    Evolution is an amazing thing. But the idea that polar bears, which have evolved over millions of years, are going to dramatically adapt to no ice (or any of the prey they hunt off it) in 20-50 years is a bit daft.

    Their behaviors might be a bit more plastic than that.

  36. harold Says:

    Like tigers, polar bears fall into the aesthetic category of “sublime” — no? Incidentally, a scientific-minded friend told me that they evolved rather recently from ordinary American black bears.

  37. Glaivester Says:

    The effort to prevent polar bears from being ut on the endangered species list is a lot more reasonable than Matt is making it out to be.

    When a species is endangered primarily by encroachment on its habitat, that is fairly easy to remedy by reducing encroachment in their habitat, which is usually a relatively small area. So perhaps two or three streams are affected.

    With the polar bears, on the other hand, the supposed endangerment is due to global warming, which is presumed to be due to the use of fossil fuels. This means that in theory, whatever agency enforces the ESA could use the endangerment of the polar bears to unilaterally impose restrictions on the use of fossil fuel. In other words, they could bypass the political debate over our greenhouse gas policy and start imposing regulations without a mechanism for direct feedback (as the regulators would not be elected officials). Whether this would actually happen or not, a lot of people are convinced that it is a possibility, and it is understandable that this would put them against the listing of the polar bear as endangered.

  38. live Says:

    They’re cute until they rip your liver out and eat it.

  39. Jay Severin Has A Small Pen1s Says:

    Maybe if her brother-in-law had shot a Polar Bear instead of a Moose he’d still be married to her sister.

  40. plooger Says:

    Has anyone followed-up on the May 25th Anchorage Daily News’ report that Palin may have misled the public (and govt agencies) regarding Alaska’s internal review of studies on climate change threats to polar bears?

    http://www.adn.com/news/environment/story/416432.html

    A newly released e-mail from last fall shows that the state’s own biologists were at odds with the Palin administration, which has consistently opposed any new federal protections for polar bears under the Endangered Species Act.

    The state’s in-house dispute seems to refute later statements by Gov. Sarah Palin that a “comprehensive review” of the federal science by state wildlife officials found no reason to support an endangered-species listing for the northern bears. The governor invoked the state’s own scientific work both in a cover letter to the state’s official polar bear comments, and in an opinion piece published in the New York Times.

    (or see here)

  41. Philidor Says:

    http://www.brightcecilia.com/pictures/watchforpalin.jpg

  42. lilly Says:

    I don’t think a polar bear will just specifically go looking for a human to eat. If they do its because humans have invaded their areas and have contributed to decreasing their source of food. And if you are one of those humans that are involved in invadeing the polar bears territory you should be eaten by a polar bear.
    Are humans that stupid to think we can pick and choose which species of animals should exsist and where they should live. What the hell is wrong with people. Live and let live.

  43. Jesse Says:

    I guess you could say nobody ever heard of B.O. until a year ago. Obama was only in congress 143 days before he ran for president.
    Why would you want a socialist who is favored by Fidel Castro?
    America is headed for worse trouble than we’re in if this non-American wins.
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xyspCRmJv7w

  44. black bears Says:

    As temperatures drop and snow flurries begin to fly in November, some Wisconsin wildlife animals begin looking for spots where they can avoid the cold by either hibernating or enter a long winter’s sleep. State wildlife officials say that

  45. battery Says:

    laptop battery
    laptop batteries

  46. car insurance Says:

    good site!

  47. viagra Says:

    viagra
    I bookmarked this site. Thank you for good job!

  48. cialis Says:

    cialis
    I bookmarked this site. Thank you for good job!

  49. fahrrad Says:

    Dies ist ein gro

  50. viagra Says:

    Excellent site. It was pleasant to me.

  51. zyban Says:

    Great site. Good info

  52. xanax Says:

    I want to say - thank you for this!
    xanax

  53. buy viagra online Says:

    buy viagra online
    Great site. Good info

  54. Hot Celebrity Wallpapers Says:

    I would love to write and say what a great job you did on this, as you have put a lot of work into it.

  55. Avaniesse Says:

    - See our Success Story with penis enlargement pills and extender.
    Large selection of penis enlargement and products.Natural Penis Enlargement Secrets Revealed!
    http://www.just4-sex.com

  56. brand viagra Says:

    Very interesting site. Hope it will always be alive!
    buy cheap viagra

  57. viagra brand Says:

    Great site. Good info
    cheap brand pfizer viagra

  58. cheap viagra Says:

    I bookmarked this site, Thank you for good job! viagra

  59. How to Get Your Ex Back Says:

    I follow your blog for a long time and must tell that your articles are always valuable to readers.

  60. Keb Says:

    Excuse me. Speak when you are angry–and you will make the best speech you’ll ever regret.
    I am from Liechtenstein and know bad English, give please true I wrote the following sentence: “We realize that most of the web shoppers are looking for a bargain, a cheap airline tickets.”

    Thank you so much for your future answers :). Keb.


Jump to Top

About Wonk Room | Contact Us | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy (off-site) | RSS | Donate
© 2005-2008 Center for American Progress Action Fund
imageRegisterimageimageRSSimageimageimage image
image
Advertisement

Visit Our Affiliated Sites

image image
image 

Books By Matthew Yglesias
Book Cover

Heads in the Sand

Buy the book


imageTopic Cloud


Featured

image
Subscribe to the Progress Report




Contact Matthew Yglesias
Use this form to contact blog author Matthew Yglesias.

Name:
Email:
Tip:
(required)


imageArchives


imageBlog Roll


imageAbout Matt YglesiasimageimageContact MeimageimageDonateimage